The Knights of Peter Claver and Ladies Auxiliary, the largest Black Catholic organization in the U.S., has spoken out against the new Black history standards in the state of Florida, which have caused an international stir since their approval on July 19.
The Knights and Ladies, who have long been outspoken on matters of racism, honed in on Florida Gov. Ron Desantis’ defense of the public education curriculum’s claim that enslaved African Americans “developed skills” that could be used for “personal benefit.”
“Slavery was a non-Christ-like practice that only provided earthly benefit to the false masters who used false interpretations of the Bible and religion to justify their sinful greed, and complete devaluation of the sanctity of human life—God’s greatest gift,” the organization said in a statement on Wednesday.
“What Governor DeSantis missed is that despite the sins of man, God will always continue to speak and bless his children. It was not slavery that provided any benefit to the enslaved, but rather God’s unfiltered and unconditional love and reach.”
DeSantis, who is himself a Catholic, has faced widespread, bipartisan scrutiny for his remarks—which he made on multiple occasions this month—amid his controversial bid for the 2024 presidency.
Though he claimed during a July 21 campaign stop in Utah that he “wasn’t involved” in formulating the new public education standards in his state, the African American History Standards Workgroup (AHSW) behind the most polarizing changes is comprised of nominees from Manny Díaz Jr., DeSantis’ hand-picked Education Commissioner.
The content in question reportedly comes from educational material provided by PragerU, a notably conservative nonprofit known for opposing viewpoints it deems as “woke.”
On July 20, the Florida Department of Education’s communications director doubled down on Twitter concerning the criticism, posting a statement from two Black AHSW members that defends the new curriculum—including the specific claim about “personal benefit.”
“The intent of this particular benchmark clarification is to show that some slaves developed highly specialized trades from which they benefited,” wrote Drs. William B. Allen and Frances Presley Rice, echoing common far-right talking points on U.S. slavery.
“Any attempt to reduce slaves to just victims of oppression fails to recognize their strength, courage and resiliency during a difficult time in American history.”
Want the truth on Florida’s African American History Standards? See statement below from experts who crafted them.
— Alex Lanfranconi (@AlexLanfran) July 20, 2023
“Any attempt to reduce slaves to just victims of oppression fails to recognize their strength, courage and resiliency during a difficult time in American history.” pic.twitter.com/7pR8GBFu2l
As DeSantis nears a breaking point in his presidential campaign—laying off a third of his staff earlier this week—critics have noted the irony of his administration’s bold attempt to recolor Black history in the very state where slavery began in earnest within what would become the United States.
Well before the arrival of the British to Virginia at Jamestown in 1619, the Spanish explorer Juan Ponce de León traveled to Florida from the island of Puerto Rico in 1513, covering a coastline span from modern-day St. Augustine, Florida, to near the city of Naples. The Black Catholic slave Esteban would arrive in Florida with Pánfilo de Narváez in 1528, and slavery would continue as a steady practice in the colony of St. Augustine beginning in 1565.
The new standards in Florida were addressed last week at the 2023 National Black Catholic Congress, where intercultural scholar Dr. Omékongo Dibinga delivered a keynote on Saturday that referenced GOP legislators’ recent attempts to censor Black history in the public education space—including in Florida.
“What do we expect to happen in a school system that already doesn’t acknowledge us? In a school system that already doesn’t want us there?” he said during his address.
Given the historical evidence contradicting his administration’s claims, DeSantis has received blowback even from his GOP colleagues, including Rep. Byron Donalds, who heads a district covering much of Southwest Florida. He noted his support for the larger program of new standards in the state but said certain aspects are flawed.
“The attempt to feature the personal benefits of slavery is wrong & needs to be adjusted. That obviously wasn't the goal & I have faith that FLDOE will correct this,” he posted on social media, linking to an interview with further comments.
“If you read what is in there now, it’s crystal clear to me that slavery was one of the darkest stains on our country, no doubt. There’s no way to get around that.”
Nate Tinner-Williams is co-founder and editor of Black Catholic Messenger.
